Many players mistakenly believe they can continue making suggestions or accusations after they have been eliminated from the game.
According to the Waddingtons Cluedo Official Rulebook, if an accusation is wrong, the player is out of the game.
Cluedo Instructions, Waddingtons Computer Edition, [page not specified]
These rules correspond to the UK edition of Cluedo.
Official Rule Breakdown
When a player makes an accusation and it is incorrect, that player is immediately removed from active play. According to the Cluedo Instructions, the player is 'out of the game and only participates in order to be a suspect and to show cards as appropriate.' This means the player can no longer make suggestions, move their piece, or make further accusations, but they must still show clue cards when requested by other players during their turns to help solve the mystery.
Step-by-Step
- Step 1: The player makes a full accusation (suspect, weapon, and room) in secret.
- Step 2: The program or players reveal the 'Murder Cards' in the envelope.
- Step 3: If the accusation does not match the cards, the player is declared out of the game.
- Step 4: The player remains in the game only to serve as a suspect and show cards when prompted.
Example Play Situation
Alice makes an accusation of Professor Plum with the Spanner in the Library. Bob reveals the cards and shows that the actual murderer is Miss Scarlett. Alice is now out of the game, but when Bob makes a suggestion later, Alice must still show him a card if she has one.
Common Misconceptions
- Thinking you can keep playing after a wrong accusation
- Believing you are completely removed from the table after being out
- Assuming you can make further suggestions after being eliminated
Quick Reference
| You Can | You Cannot |
|---|---|
| You can show cards to other players when asked | You cannot make any further questions |
| You can act as a suspect for others' investigations | You cannot make any further accusations |
| You cannot move your piece on the board |
Frequently Asked Questions
- What is the official rule for making a wrong accusation in Cluedo?
- The player is out of the game but must still show cards as a suspect.
- Can I keep playing if I guess the wrong person?
- No, you are out of the game, though you still show cards for others.
- What happens if I fail to show a card during a suggestion?
- You are penalised by being out of the game, similar to a wrong accusation.
- Do I have to show my cards after I am eliminated?
- Yes, you participate only to be a suspect and show cards as appropriate.